Pundit Wire
Where Political Speechwriters Comment on the News

Tag Archives: Medicare

The war to reform American medicine has been won.

LyndonJohnsonSigningMedicareBillThe transformation began with the enactment of Medicare and medicaid during the Johnson years — which allowed prices to be contained as a growing percentage of bills were paid by large entities, especially the government — and the HMO act during the Nixon years — which endorsed the idea of an efficient system where experts decided on how to treat any problem,  effectively setting limits on volume.

Once the tools were in place to control both price and volume, the rest was just fine tuning,  which is still ongoing.  The basic principles were ratified in Obamacare and are no longer under serious challenge.  The change hasn’t relied entirely on government action, but reflects private sector movement in the same direction.

Read More »
Posted in Health, Politics, U.S. | Also tagged , , , | Leave a comment

So What’s the Problem?

healthcare If the good news we’ve been hearing about American health costs in the past few months turns out to be the new norm – it’s too early to tell – then much of today’s political debate is wildly misguided. Consultants predict 2014 will see abnormally low inflation, again. Medicare spending per beneficiary is dropping more than previously anticipated. And new tools provided by Obamacare to constrain costs could accelerate these trends.

Read More »
Posted in Business, General, Health, Media, U.S. | Also tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Adding Doctors Inflates Bills Without Aiding Health

Congresspeople Schwartz and Schock While much of Washington worries about how to constrain Medicare costs, two contrarian legislators want the program to spend $1 billion more annually to fund residency training for new doctors.

Their plan responds to a projected physician shortage. There’s heated debate about whether there will be a physician deficit in the future and, if so, how to best respond. There’s less debate about whether increasing the physician supply will increase our medical bills. It’s intuitive. More doctors will not only bill more so they can make an adequate living, but will order more tests and referrals. Normal economic logic that increased supply drives prices down doesn’t work in medicine.

Read More »
Posted in Business, General, Health, Politics, U.S. | Also tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Means-Tested Medicare Accelerates Down Track

Sample Medicare Card Rich people have paid more for Medicare coverage since the program began in 1966. Subsequent changes have regularly increased the extra amount those with high incomes must pay for coverage. That history often seems totally forgotten in today’s Medicare reform debate about whether the program should be means-tested so as to require upper-income people to pay more.

In fact, that’s been a basic component of the program from the start, which makes the current debate so distracting and confusing. The real question is how much extra the rich should pay.

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, U.S. | Also tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Recasting the Medical Morality Play

Doctor and patient Many Americans have an unhelpful habit of viewing the health reform debate as a morality play where those who treat us, usually doctors and hospitals, are viewed as the good guys and those who pay for those services, generally insurance companies or government programs like Medicare, are seen as villains.

When a physician suggests another test, we assume that they’re trying to be helpful rather than merely increase their income. When an insurer refuses to pay for a test proven unreliable or has a less expensive alternative, we assume that the decision comes from heartless profit-maximizing bean counters.

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, U.S. | Also tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Maybe We Don’t Have a Spending Problem After All

Boehner & Obama House Speaker John Boehner recently confided in an interview that what astonished him most during his marathon negotiations with President Obama on avoiding the fiscal cliff was when Mr. Obama said to him, “We don’t have a spending problem.”

When I read that, I was reduced to sputtering indignation: “We don’t have a spending problem??!! What planet is that man living on??!!”

And yet, just a couple of days later, I read a column by Matt Steinglass in the January 8 issue of the Economist that made me realize that Mr. Obama was entirely right. We don’t have a spending problem; we have a tax problem.

Read More »
Posted in Business, Economy, General, Health, International, Political Rhetoric, Politics, U.S. | Also tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Death to Social Security Trust Funds


The annual report of the Social Security trustees predicting when the various funds (retirement, Medicare and disability) will be depleted has become a meaningless rite of Spring that provides more heat than light. The news is always viewed as bad and ignored, a response that’s helpful only to those who have a vested interest in suggesting that our government is dysfunctional.

Read More »
Posted in Business, Culture, Economy, General, Politics, U.S. | Also tagged , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Boom to Bust to Deductible: Hegel Knows Best


You can find me at the White House every day this week. Well, not personally, but my ears burn as I become the subject of a big conversation.

Shortly after World War II, I was a bump and reached age zero in summer of 1946. Run the math, and you’ll see I move into Medicare this summer.

Read More »
Posted in Economy, General, Health, Political Rhetoric, Politics, U.S. | Also tagged , | Leave a comment