Pundit Wire

Scotland Votes: the Logic and Rhetoric of the Independence Campaign

Scotland vote noScotland has voted decisively against breaking from the United Kingdom and becoming an independent country. Some thoughts on the big picture logic and rhetoric of the campaign.

Read More »
Also posted in Campaigns & Elections, International, Politics | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Who will govern England if the Scots split?

Parliament All kinds of questions are being asked about what will happen if Scotland votes to leave the United Kingdom on September 18. How will the national debt and the North Sea oil and gas reserves be divided? What about fishing rights? Will Scotland be allowed to keep the pound? Where will the Royal Navy base its nuclear submarines, since they are not welcome in Scotland? What will the remainder of the United Kingdom do for a flag if the white cross of St. Andrew on a blue field is ripped from the Union Jack?

Read More »
Also posted in Campaigns & Elections, Culture, General, History, International, Labor | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Brat — The protesting Protestant?

dave brat There’s an early Philip Roth story about a bunch of Jewish kids in Hebrew school trying to figure out whether Jesus lived or not.

“The Catholics,” Itzie Lieberman says, “they believe in Jesus Christ, that he’s God.”

Lieberman, Roth adds, “used ‘the Catholics’ in its broadest sense — to include the Protestants.”

I confess, when I was a kid in a largely Jewish town, I was similarly confused. I think I have it straight, now. But I was confused again this week, reading about Dave Brat’s surprising primary election win over Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA)…

Read More »
Also posted in Campaigns & Elections, Culture, General, Politics, Religion, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments closed

In Search of a Message — Dems Have a Way to Go

Screen Shot 2014-04-06 at 11.34.18 PM If you were a recent college grad or drop out with no job or underemployed or selling your mind and body as an unpaid intern, do you give a (bleep) about the Koch brothers?

Read More »
Also posted in Campaigns & Elections, Culture, Economy, General, History, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Animal, Vegetable, Mineral: Is West ‘Provoking’ Russia?

russiaFascinating question: if X responds badly to your action and cites your action as a reason for behaving badly, how far are you responsible for what X does?

Three scenarios…

Read More »
Also posted in General, International, National Security | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

That’s blasphemy!

ingersol The United States Commission on International Religious Freedom, an agency charged by Congress with monitoring liberty of conscience around the world, has just issued a report on prosecutions for blasphemy in other countries.

Predictably, the leading offenders are Muslim countries, such as Egypt, Iran, Bangladesh, Sudan, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan. Pakistan is cited as “the most egregious example … where blasphemy charges are common and numerous individuals are in prison, with a high number sentenced to death or life terms.”

Read More »
Also posted in Civil Rights, General, History, International, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Vladimir Putin, Crimea and ‘Double Standards’

putin On 18 March Russia’s President Vladimir Putin delivered a major speech to Russia’s political elite aimed at explaining Russia’s policy towards Crimea and Ukraine. Plenty of commentators have analysed it (and attacked it mercilessly) on points of substance. See for example this brisk piece for Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty…

Read More »
Also posted in Campaigns & Elections, Civil Rights, General, History, National Security | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Editor’s Note: Crafting a Response

mcmorris rodgers The State of the Union is one of America’s most famous speech giving traditions. The House chamber is bright at speech-time, buzzing with energy. It’s filled to capacity with Members of Congress, military brass, Supreme Court Justices, and top luminaries. For every paragraph the president delivers, there is at least some applause, and usually ovation.

Read More »
Also posted in Editor's Note, General, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment