Pundit Wire

Author Archives: Jim Jaffe

Obamacare Prescription: Keep Calm and Carry On

President Obama signing the Affordable Care Act There’s growing angst in the health reform community that Obamacare is not succeeding as it should. Perhaps that’s nothing more than a response to the growing popularity of immigration and tax reform.

The basic premise of the complaint, as I understand it, is that the infrastructure is not as far along as some would like, which may lead to confusion when major elements become effective next year, that Americans remain ambivalent about the bill because they don’t know what it does for them and that this lack of enthusiasm – coupled with continued GOP opposition – will yield a bad result in Congressional elections next year.

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Adding Doctors Inflates Bills Without Aiding Health

Congresspeople Schwartz and Schock While much of Washington worries about how to constrain Medicare costs, two contrarian legislators want the program to spend $1 billion more annually to fund residency training for new doctors.

Their plan responds to a projected physician shortage. There’s heated debate about whether there will be a physician deficit in the future and, if so, how to best respond. There’s less debate about whether increasing the physician supply will increase our medical bills. It’s intuitive. More doctors will not only bill more so they can make an adequate living, but will order more tests and referrals. Normal economic logic that increased supply drives prices down doesn’t work in medicine.

Read More »
Posted in Business, Health, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Means-Tested Medicare Accelerates Down Track

Sample Medicare Card Rich people have paid more for Medicare coverage since the program began in 1966. Subsequent changes have regularly increased the extra amount those with high incomes must pay for coverage. That history often seems totally forgotten in today’s Medicare reform debate about whether the program should be means-tested so as to require upper-income people to pay more.

In fact, that’s been a basic component of the program from the start, which makes the current debate so distracting and confusing. The real question is how much extra the rich should pay.

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Recasting the Medical Morality Play

Doctor and patient Many Americans have an unhelpful habit of viewing the health reform debate as a morality play where those who treat us, usually doctors and hospitals, are viewed as the good guys and those who pay for those services, generally insurance companies or government programs like Medicare, are seen as villains.

When a physician suggests another test, we assume that they’re trying to be helpful rather than merely increase their income. When an insurer refuses to pay for a test proven unreliable or has a less expensive alternative, we assume that the decision comes from heartless profit-maximizing bean counters.

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Attention Surgery Shoppers

Surgery If you’re an uninsured New Yorker shopping for a hip replacement, the going rate in Manhattan is $18,260. If that sounds steep and you’re willing to try medical tourism, the rate drops to $7,500 in Boston, $7,099 in Baltimore or $6,399 in Washington.

If you’re willing to go further afield, there are seeming bargains available elsewhere including these:

  • Portland, Oregon: $4,366
  • Tampa, Florida: $3,039
Read More »
Posted in General, Health, U.S. | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Moderate Republicans — An Endangered Species

Speaker Boehner In a surprising outcome better ascribed to the law of unanticipated consequences than a clever plot, a small group of moderate Republicans, particularly in the House of Representatives, are now poised to play an extremely powerful pivotal role.

This group, recently nominated for inclusion in the endangered species list, was given this power by their more conservative colleagues who rejected a compromise budget proposal — the so-called Plan B — recommended by House Speaker John Boehner. That created an unsettled situation that will likely be resolved when someone comes up with a plan that can win the support of House Democrats as well as enough moderate Republicans to put it over the top.

Read More »
Posted in Campaigns & Elections, Economy, General, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Tax Reform — Political Opiate?

2012 State of the Union No issue with less potential impact on public good gets more attention than tax reform. It is possible to argue that the amount of taxes collected from the public impacts the national economy, but there’s no compelling evidence suggesting that the mechanism used (income tax vs. value-added tax vs. personal property tax) makes much difference.

Read More »
Posted in Business, Economy, General, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

A Return to Business as Usual?

Fiscal Cliff Talks It’s looking like a very merry holiday season with an extremely prosperous new year ahead for the lobbying community. Fiscal austerity is an ill wind that does blow some good to those paid to influence where the painful spending cuts will be made. And the growing possibility of tax reform is icing on the cake.

Read More »
Posted in Business, Economy, General, International, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment