Pundit Wire

Author Archives: Charles Crawford

The Death of Ambassador Chris Stevens: Honesty and Accuracy

President Obama UN Speech One question I put into my Speechwriting training courses (and into any course I give) is this:

What is the Supreme Quality in any piece of professional work such as a speech? Choose from the following options:

  • Simple message
  • Strong structure
  • Accuracy
  • Loyalty
  • Energy + commitment
  • Clear language
  • Honesty + integrity
Read More »
Posted in Campaigns & Elections, General, International, National Security, Political Rhetoric, Politics, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Help! I’ve been Framed!

David Axelrod A key skill taught to mediators and negotiators is how to ‘reframe’ issues. This means moving the conversation to a higher level of generalisation. A form of bold simplification that (as the jargon has it) takes all concerned from their obvious Positions to less obvious Interests and Needs. And thereby creates space for strategic compromises.

Thus a haggle over compensation payments: “I think I’m hearing from you that you can be flexible on phasing these payments, but you really need certainty on the total?” The reframing question opens the idea of trading Money against Time.

Framing is all around us these days in politics. Organisation activist Saul Alinsky featured it prominently in his Rules for Radicals: “Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.”

Read More »
Posted in Culture, General, Political Rhetoric | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Remembering Margaret Thatcher

Margaret Thatcher Portrait Several years back I had the great pleasure of taking part in a small private dinner at which Baroness Thatcher was the guest of honour.

By then she was frail but still well able to capture the table with some steely wit and insight. I was struck by how often she cited her Christian beliefs, mustering a heartening consensus that Jesus had been more than ‘sound’ in his stout conservative principles.

As the dinner concluded she wistfully said that she was so grateful to have such friends who appreciated her work, “No-one ever says thank you to politicians.”

Read More »
Posted in General, International | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Reverse the PowerPoint Death Spiral to Mediocrity! Now!

PowerPoint Imagine a product that is so successful that many people start hating it, to the point of blaming intellectual decline and other social problems on its very ubiquity. Welcome to PowerPoint.

The expression “Death by PowerPoint” generates about (sic) 4,220,000 results via Google, with myriad links to horrible examples of PowerPoint presentations and surveys that rehearse the damage PowerPoint can cause to thinking minds. “PowerPoint Poisoning” gives nearly 1,000,000 Google results, not bad for a contrived phrase. Who knows, maybe PowerPoint Death Spiral to Mediocrity will now surge up the Google ratings charts.

Read More »
Posted in General, Technology | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Just Say No to Musty, Needy Speeches

David Miliband America! Brace yourself! David Miliband is coming to New York to lead the International Rescue Committee.

David Miliband is hailed in British and wider progressive circles as someone with preternaturally high mental powers. On my own brief encounters with him I have found him charming and clever. However, he had the misfortune to serve as UK Foreign Secretary under the doomed premiership of Gordon Brown, and as the creaking Labour ship pushed full steam ahead to defeat he had few opportunities to do anything useful.

One of the things you nonetheless might expect a staggeringly able British Foreign Minister to do is make powerful, interesting speeches.

Read More »
Posted in General, International, Political Rhetoric, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Language of International Friendship: President Obama in Israel

President Obama in Israel Some issues really are “binary.” Take the Judgement of Solomon. Two women each claimed that a baby belonged to them. King Solomon of Israel proposed to cut the baby in two pieces, an outcome the false mother accepted.

Babies are either dead or alive. Under international law states either exist or they don’t. If they exist they either have clear, accepted borders, or they don’t.

There are exceptions and anomalies. But the toughest problems of international politics arise around these simple propositions.

Read More »
Posted in General, International, U.S. | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

The Language of Deflecting Blame

David Nicholson Last week here I looked at British Prime Minister David Cameron’s verbal manoeuvrings around apologising (or not) for the massacre perpetrated by British colonial troops in Amritsar in India in 1919. Most observers concluded that he struck a respectful and appropriate tone in what he said and did.

In 2010 British Minister for Europe David Lidington had to tackle a similar but rather more recent problem: what, if anything, should the British government do now about British army complicity in massacres committed by Tito’s communists of hundreds of thousands of their fellow Yugoslav citizens back in 1945?

Read More »
Posted in General, Health, International | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Political Language of Apology (or Not)

Prime Minister Cameron Prime Minister David Cameron’s recent visit to India gave us another notable example of the “political apology.”

In Punjab in 1919 public discontent with British colonial rule was growing. In Amritsar ruthless but stupid Brig-General Reginald Dyer ordered his troops to fire at point-blank range on a large crowd of Indian protesters. Hundreds died. This massacre was denounced in Parliament in London by Winston Churchill, then Secretary of State for War and no slouch as a public speaker…

Read More »
Posted in General, International, Political Rhetoric | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment